Skip to main content
Sauce and Preserves Recipe

Nonna’s Sunday Sauce

Andrea Clapp

Nonna’s Sunday Sauce

Andrea Clapp

Every time I make this sauce my kitchen is filled with fond memories of lazy summer Sunday afternoons spent at my Nonna and Papa’s house. Papa would take my brother, sister and I, along with whatever cousins were there (a lot-we’re Italian), out back to the swimming pool that was very near his big garden, while Nonna was busy making a feast in the kitchen. We’d splash in the pool for a while, run barefoot in Papa’s garden feeling the mud squish between our toes, and then he’d chase us with the garden hose to rinse our feet...repeat over and over again. Just about the time our tummies would begin to grumble, the heavenly scent of Nonna’s Sunday Sauce would fill the air.... Yes, it’s possible to taste a childhood memory!

Serves 4 to 6


1tbsp olive oil
1+ bulb garlic, minced
1 large onion, diced
2lbs Italian Sausage (or ground beef)
8oz Porcini or button mushrooms, sliced
4lbs peeled, diced tomatoes
1-12oz can of tomato paste
Mix of fresh herbs- basil, rosemary, thyme, oregano, parsley, marjoram, sage (Sub for 2 tbsp of dried Italian seasoning)
Salt and pepper to taste


Drizzle a large saucepan with olive oil over medium heat. Then add Italian sausage, minced garlic, diced onion, and sliced mushrooms. Saute until the sausage is browned, then drain excess liquids.

Making sure the meat is evenly crumbled, return the pan to medium heat and add peeled, diced tomatoes and tomato paste, salt and pepper to taste. Stir until all ingredients are mixed well.

Spread herbs evenly between two sheets of waxed paper and gently press with a rolling pin for several passes to express the flavors. Then chop and add to the saucepan

Reduce heat and simmer on low for several hours, stirring as needed to keep the bottom and sides from sticking. (This can also be made in a crock pot or roasted in the oven all day while you are working or out in the garden.)

Serve over fresh pasta, use as a braising sauce for homemade braciole, add to lasagna, or it even makes for a great soup base- just add fresh vegetables, noodles and beef stock.

Reader Comments

  • Avatar Subscriber

    Certainly childhood memories in dear old Malta of years gone by.
    Ron Fenech

  • Avatar Subscriber

    this is insane
    great tomatoing

    i havent tried it but its definately so good

  • Avatar Subscriber

    Would Thorburn’s Terra Cotta do well with this recipe? I have some that will need to be cooked due to unusable portions I’ll be cutting off and chopping the rest. I’d love to make them into a tasty sauce like this one. Thanks!

    • Dorota
      Dorota Editor
      Website Content Director

      Yes, of course, you can use Thorburn’s Terra Cotta tomatoes for this recipe. The sauce will differ in color, and will not be deep red if you use different colored tomatoes, but the taste will be great for sure! Happy cooking!

      • Avatar Subscriber

        Sounds wonderful. Thank you! I will try it!

      • Avatar Subscriber

        It was excellent. I’m about to make another batch! Thank you!


Try it

Sign up for a free membership and set up your dashboard. Get a taste of our rich content and view up to 12 tomatoes, recipes, bugs, articles, and videos on us!